We’re available 24/7
1300 375 325
Book a plumber
We’re available 24/7

Ultimate Guide On Gas Vs Electric Hot Water Heaters

Choosing the right hot water system for your home is a crucial decision affecting your daily comfort, energy bills, and environmental footprint. In the bustling cities of Sydney and Melbourne, where Dr Leak Plumbing proudly offers its expert services, homeowners often find themselves weighing the pros and cons of gas vs electric hot water systems. This guide aims to provide you with a comprehensive understanding of both options, helping you make an informed decision that suits your lifestyle and needs.

Overview of the debate: gas vs electric hot water systems

The debate between gas and electric hot water systems is longstanding, with each type offering distinct benefits and drawbacks. The choice often boils down to energy efficiency, cost, environmental impact, and installation requirements. In Sydney and Melbourne, where energy costs and sustainability are significant considerations for many households, understanding these differences is key to selecting the right system.

Understanding gas hot water systems

How Gas Hot Water Systems Work

Gas hot water systems operate by burning natural gas or LPG (liquefied petroleum gas) to heat water. These systems can be storage-based, where heated water is stored in an insulated tank for later use, or continuous flow systems heat water on demand. In cities like Sydney and Melbourne, where natural gas and LPG are readily available, gas hot water systems are popular for their efficiency and reliability.

Advantages of Gas Hot Water Systems

  1. Cost-Effective Operation: Generally, gas hot water systems have lower running costs compared to electric systems, especially if connected to natural gas lines, making them an economical choice in the long run.
  2. Rapid Heating: Gas systems typically heat water faster than electric systems, ensuring a steady supply of hot water even during peak usage times.
  3. Less Dependency on Electricity: In areas prone to power outages, gas systems offer the advantage of continued operation, as they don't rely on electricity.
  4. Environmental Considerations: Natural gas is a cleaner-burning fuel compared to coal-generated electricity, often used in Australia, making gas systems a more environmentally friendly option.

Potential Drawbacks

  1. Higher Initial Costs: The installation of a gas hot water system, particularly if switching from an electric system, can be more expensive due to the need for gas lines and venting systems.
  2. Maintenance Requirements: Gas systems may require more frequent maintenance checks by professionals like Dr Leak Plumbing to ensure safety and efficiency.
  3. Availability of Gas: In some areas, particularly remote locations outside Sydney and Melbourne, connection to natural gas lines may not be feasible, necessitating the use of more expensive LPG.

Cost comparison gas vs electric hot water

Initial Installation Costs

  • Electric Systems: Generally have lower initial installation costs due to simpler setup requirements. This is particularly advantageous for homes in Sydney and Melbourne that are not already equipped with gas infrastructure.
  • Gas Systems: Can be more expensive to install, especially if the property requires new gas lines or modifications for gas storage and venting.

Long-term Running Costs

  • Electric Systems: Tend to have higher ongoing running costs, as electricity rates are usually higher than gas. This can add up over time, making them less cost-effective in the long run.
  • Gas Systems: Typically offer lower running costs, especially for homes connected to natural gas. This can result in significant savings over the lifespan of the system.

Environmental impact

Energy Efficiency of Gas vs Electric Systems

  • Gas Systems: Tend to be more energy-efficient than electric systems, especially if they are modern condensing models. They use less energy to heat the same amount of water compared to electric systems, which is a crucial factor for environmentally conscious homeowners in Sydney and Melbourne.
  • Electric Systems: While traditionally less efficient, advancements in technology, such as heat pump electric water heaters, have significantly improved their energy efficiency. Additionally, if the electricity is sourced from renewable energy, their environmental impact can be considerably reduced.

Carbon Footprint Considerations

  • Gas Systems: Although they burn fossil fuels, natural gas systems generally have a lower carbon footprint than traditional electric systems, especially in areas where electricity is primarily generated from coal or other non-renewable sources.
  • Electric Systems: The carbon footprint can vary greatly depending on the source of electricity. In regions with a high proportion of renewable energy in the grid, such as certain areas of Sydney and Melbourne, electric systems can be a more environmentally friendly option.

Maintenance & longevity

Maintenance Requirements for Gas and Electric Systems

  • Gas Systems: Require regular maintenance to ensure safety and efficiency. This includes checks for gas leaks, venting system integrity, and burner condition. Professional servicing by a qualified technician, like those at Dr Leak Plumbing, is recommended.
  • Electric Systems: Generally have lower maintenance requirements. However, periodic checks of the heating element, thermostat, and tank condition are still necessary to ensure optimal performance.

Expected Lifespan and Durability

  • Gas Systems: Typically have a longer lifespan, often lasting up to 20 years with proper maintenance.
  • Electric Systems: Usually have a shorter lifespan compared to gas systems, averaging around 10-15 years. However, this can vary based on the model and maintenance.

Making the right choice for your home

Factors to Consider

  • Household Size and Hot Water Usage: Larger families or households with high hot water demand may find gas systems more suitable due to their rapid heating capability and cost-effectiveness for larger volumes of water.
  • Availability of Energy Sources: Consider the availability and cost of natural gas vs electricity in your area. In some parts of Sydney and Melbourne, one may be more accessible or cost-effective than the other.
  • Space and Installation Constraints: Electric systems offer more flexibility in installation location, which can be a deciding factor in homes with limited space.

How to Determine the Best Fit for Your Needs

  • Assess Your Hot Water Needs: Evaluate your household's daily hot water usage patterns to determine the capacity and type of system that would best meet your needs.
  • Consider Future Energy Costs and Environmental Goals: Factor in potential changes in energy costs and your personal or household goals for reducing environmental impact.
  • Consult with Professionals: Seek advice from experienced professionals like Dr Leak Plumbing, who can provide insights specific to Sydney and Melbourne's unique conditions and help you make an informed decision.


Recap of Key Points

In this comprehensive guide, we've explored the key aspects of gas and electric hot water systems, considering their operational mechanisms, costs, environmental impacts, maintenance needs, and longevity. Both systems have their unique advantages and drawbacks, making the choice largely dependent on individual circumstances and preferences.

Final Thoughts on Making an Informed Decision

Choosing between a gas and electric hot water system is a significant decision for any homeowner, especially in areas like Sydney and Melbourne where energy efficiency and environmental sustainability are increasingly important. Consider your household's specific needs, the long-term costs, and the environmental impact of each option. Consulting with experienced professionals like Dr Leak Plumbing can provide valuable insights tailored to your situation, ensuring you make the most informed decision for your home.

What some of our clients say

Anytime Fitness
First National Real Estate
Macquarie Centre
Orangetheory Fitness
Rain & Horne
1300 375 325
Book Online